Results of our studies

MOSCOW, February 15, 2008 Russian Public Opinion Research Center (VCIOM) presents information on how Russians estimate the deed of Vitaly Kaloev, who killed the flying control officer in Switzerland that was to blame for the air crash that had taken the lives of the whole Kaloev's family and also what they think of appointing Kaloev Deputy Minister of Construction in Northern Ossetia

Nearly half of Russians, 44%, identify that Kaloev is a criminal but still deserves indulgence in view of the factual background. Every fourth respondent (27%) thinks of him not as a criminal, but rather as the real man, who has taken revenge in the name of his family and does not deserve to be punished. No more than 8% of respondents indicate, that he has committed a crime and should suffer the punishment with all severity of the law. Every fifth (21%) finds it hard to provide an answer to this question. The point of view that blood feud in this case is not a crime finds more understanding in Southern (39%), Far East (33%) and Volga (30%) federal districts.

The fact that Kaloev was appointed Deputy Minister of Construction of Northern Ossetia after his jail release from the Swiss prison, has received an ambiguous reaction in the Russian society. 29% of respondents believe that it is a well-deserved reward to a worthy person, an encouragement to the real man. Nearly as many respondents (26%), however, specify that an appointment like that given to a criminal challenges the moral and legal norms and discredits Russia in the eyes of the Europeans. Nearly half of respondents find it hard to provide an answer to this question.

Regional differences in the estimation of this decision done by the authorities of Northern Ossetia are worth mentioning. Residents of Southern (41% versus 17%), Far East (35% versus 27%) and Central (30% versus 23%) federal districts are more likely to favourKaloev’s appointment. However, residents of Ural (36% versus 18 %), Siberian (31% versus 18%) and North West (29% versus 25%) districts provide negative estimations more often. The estimations of people living in Volga FD were split into two equal parts (29% in each of the two groups).

To conclude, the overwhelming majority of respondents (65%) consider Kaloev to be an unfortunate person, a prey of circumstances. 8% call him a criminal, and 5% think of him as a hero, a model to be followed and imitated.

The initiative all-Russia opinion poll was conducted by VCIOM on January 8-9, 2008. 1600 respondents were interviewed in 153 population areas of 46 regions of Russia. The statistical error does not exceed 3.4%     

 

The Russian Citizen Vitaly Kaloev was convicted for murder of a flying control officer of the “Skyguard” airlines, who was to blame for the air crash between a Russian TU-154 and another plane that took place over Switzerland. Kaloev's whole family died in this air crash.

How would you characterize what Vitaly Kaloev did?

 

Total respondents

Federal Districts*

CFD

NWFD

SFD

VFD

UFD

SFD

FEFD

Kaloev is a criminal, but deserves indulgence in view of the factual background

44

47

53

34

42

44

54

31

Kaloev is not a criminal at all but a real man who took revenge in the name of his family, he does not deserve any punishment

27

25

20

39

30

19

19

33

Kaloev has committed a crime and deserves to be punished with all severity of the law

8

9

8

8

7

10

6

10

Hard to say

21

19

19

19

21

27

21

26

Vitaly Kaloev was released from a Swiss prison some time ago. He was appointed Deputy Minister of Construction in his homeland, Northern Ossetia. How would you estimate this appointment?

 

Total respondents

Federal Districts*

CFD

NWFD

SFD

VFD

UFD

SFD

DFD

This a well-deserved award to a worthy person, an encouragement to the real man

29

30

25

41

29

18

18

35

An appointment like that given to a criminal is an unjust decision that challenges the moral and legal norms and discredits Russia in the eyes of the Europeans

26

23

29

17

29

36

31

27

Hard to say

45

47

46

42

42

46

51

38

Vitaly Kaloev is a...

 

Total respondents

Federal Districts*

CFD

NWFD

SFD

VFD

UFD

SFD

DFD

A miserable man, a prey to circumstances

65

65

71

62

68

52

71

60

A hero, a hero, a model to be followed and imitated

5

9

-

8

4

3

4

3

A criminal

8

8

8

8

8

14

7

10

A madman

2

2

-

-

3

3

3

3

Other option

2

2

-

1

3

7

-

3

Hard to say

18

14

21

21

14

21

15

21


Read the article in Russian