Results of our studies

MOSCOW, October 22, 2007 Russian Public Opinion Research Center (VCIOM) presents information concerning how Russians evaluate the repressions that took place in 1937 and the following years.

After seventy years have passed, the year of 1937 still remains in the memory of every second Russian (47%) primarily as the symbol of Stalin's terror and mass repressions, 44% of respondents find it difficult to come up with an answer as to what events of any significance happened at that time. 1-3% of respondents for each option propose an alternative version of events that year connecting them with mass famine, industrial growth, industrialization, collectivization of the country, the beginning of fascism in Europe, or just "difficult times for all people in general".

Three fourths of respondents, 76%, find it difficult today to mention any particular surnames of well-known people who suffered from repressions during those years. This question causes the greatest difficulty among the young people of 18-24 years of age (88%). More frequently than others they manage to recall in this respect M. Tukhachevskiy (6%), A. Solzhenitsyn (4%), V. Blyukher (3%), N. Bukharin, A. Sakharov (2% per option), N. Vavilov, G. Zhzhenov, G. Zhukov, G. Zinovjev, L. Kamenev, S. Kirov, S. Korolev, O. Mandelstam, K. Rokossovsky, L. Trotsky (1% per option).

Every fifth respondent today can think of his or her relatives, who died during that period of time or were sentenced to a penal in Stalin camps (ranging from 15% among young people to 29% of respondents of 60 years and older). 50% of respondents are quite sure that there were no political prisoners in their family, 24% find it difficult to provide an answer to this question.

The relative majority of respondents, 36%, estimate the number of victims of Stalin's repressions as equalling to several million people; another 20% consider it to have been several hundred thousand, 13% assume that Stalin's repressions accounted for several tens of millions of victims, and only 4% mention several tens of thousands. All age groups of respondents most frequently consider the number of victims to have been several million people.

From the repressions of those years most of all suffered the people prominent in cultural matters, science and art, as 51% respondent of those interrogated identify, to be followed by soldiers (31%), "the ordinary citizens, everyone taken at random" (21%), "Jews, Latvians, representatives of other national minorities" (18%), clergymen (18%), peasants (17%), workers (16%), party workers (14%), political opposition to Stalin (11%); NKVD workers and workers of other power structures (6%). Only 5% consider that "spies and wreckers", and 2% that "speculators, thieves and bandits" were the ones who predominantly suffered.

In the opinion of a half of respondents (51%), in essence honest and innocent citizens, who were maligned, were then the ones to undergo repressions. One third (32%) assumes that part of those punished was guilty, but the other part was not. Only 2% of respondents consider that these were chiefly wreckers and enemies of the Soviet regime, and another 4% note that in essence these were all communists, guilty at least of the fact that they themselves during the Civil War and in the early years of the Soviet regime had committed numerous crimes. Respondents of all generations are inclined to think that predominantly honest people suffered.

Only 2% of respondents consider the repressions of those years to have been the correct and necessary step of the Soviet regime. 16% share version about exaggerations: it was necessary to fight with the enemies of the people in those years, but "in to the flame of fight" many innocent people suffered. 19% call what happened in 1937 the large error of Stalin; just as many respondents characterize repressions as a crime committed in cold blood, carried out by Stalin personally, to which there can be no justification. And the most wide-spread estimation (give by 33% of respondents) is that not Stalin alone was guilty of the repressions but the entire system of government created by him. The higher the level of education the respondents had, the more inclined they were to blame the system (ranging from 28% in the group with less than elementary education to 38% in the group with higher and uncompleted highest education), and the less they support the version of "exaggerations" (22% and 14%).

The majority of Russians (70%) negatively evaluate the "cleaning" of the military leaders in 1937, considering this as one of the reasons of the failures of our army at the beginning of the war in 1941-1945. Only 9% of respondents assume that the repressions in no way affected the defence capability of our country, but 3% even think that "cleaning" strengthened the Soviet Army.

The initiative All-Russia opinion poll was conducted by VCIOM on October 6-7, 2007. 1600 respondents were interviewed in 153 population areas of 46 regions of Russia. The statistical error does not exceed 3.4%.

 

And now let us try to remember some of the events that took place 70 years ago. What impressions, recollections or associations do you have with the year 1937? What are the most important events that took place in the country at that time? (A free-answer question, up to three responses)

 

Total respondents

Age, years

18-24

25-34

35-44

45-59

60 and more

It was a year of mass repressions

47

23

36

56

56

51

A famine in the country

3

1

1

3

3

5

A time of industrial growth, industrialization, a great construction period in the country

3

1

2

2

4

6

Hard times

3

2

5

2

3

4

Lawlessness of the authorities, disorders in the country

2

2

1

1

3

2

The time of Stalin's rule

2

2

3

1

2

3

Stalin's personality cult

2

1

2

2

2

1

The appearance of fascism in Italy, Germany, getting ready for the war

2

1

3

1

2

2

Nothing good happened

2

1

3

2

1

3

Collectivization of agriculture

1

0

1

1

1

1

Elimination of the intelligentsia

1

0

1

1

1

2

Other

1

0

1

0

1

3

Hard to say

44

69

53

42

35

32

1937 has cut into the memories of many as the year of mass repressions, "Stalin terror". Please, try to mention the most famous people who suffered from the repressions of 1937 and the following years (A free-answer question, up to three responses)

Tukhachevsky

6

Solzhenitsyn

4

Blyukher

3

Bukharin

2

Sakharov

2

Vavilov

1

Zhzhenov

1

Zhukov

1

Zinovjev

1

Kamenev

1

Kirov

1

Korolev

1

Mandelstam

1

Rokossovsky

1

Trotsky

1

Military leaders

3

Intelligentsia

2

Doctors (The doctors' plot)

1

Scientists

1

Political leaders

1

Other

2

Hard to say

76

Were there among your relatives people who died in custody or was sentenced to a penal in a Stalin's camp?

 

Total respondents

Age, years

18-24

25-34

35-44

45-59

60 and more

Yes, there were

20

15

14

20

20

29

No, there were not

50

42

50

50

55

50

I do not know for sure

24

33

29

26

18

17

Hard to say

6

10

7

4

7

4

What number according to your estimation the number of victims reached?

 

Total respondents

Age, years

18-24

25-34

35-44

45-59

60 and more

Several tens of thousand people

4

3

3

4

5

5

Several hundred thousand people  

20

16

17

21

22

20

Several million people

36

29

40

39

37

32

Several tens of million people

13

14

10

14

13

15

Hard to say

27

38

30

22

23

28

What categories of citizens do you think suffered most from Stalin's repressions? (a close-end question, one response possible)

Intelligentsia , people prominent in cultural matters, science and art

51

The military

31

the ordinary citizens, everyone taken at random

21

Jews, Latvians, representatives of other national minorities

18

The clergymen

18

Peasants

17

Workers

16

Party workers

14

Political opposition to Stalin

11

NKVD workers and workers of other power structures

6

Spies and wreckers

5

speculators, thieves and bandits

2

Other

1

Hard to say

11

Do you think that citizens who had to endure repressions were really guilty of something? (a close-end question, one response possible)

 

Total respondents

Age, years

18-24

25-34

35-44

45-59

60 and more

They mostly were, these were wreckers and enemies of the Soviet state

2

1

1

1

1

3

Mostly so, as primarily repressed were communists, guilty at least by the fact that they themselves during the Civil War and in the early years of the Soviet regime had committed numerous crimes

4

7

2

3

4

3

Part of those punished was guilty, but the other part was not

32

29

35

33

32

32

Generally not, in essence honest and innocent citizens, who were maligned

51

45

46

53

51

55

Hard to say

11

18

16

10

12

7

How would you characterize the repressions of those years? (a close-end question, one response possible)

 

Total respondents

Level of Education

Elementary or lower, junior secondary education

Secondary education (school or vocational school)

Post-secondary education  (technical school)

Incomplete higher education (no less than 6 semesters),  higher education

The repressions of those years were the correct and necessary step of the Soviet regime

2

2

2

1

1

It was necessary to fight with the enemies of the people in those years, but "in to the flame of fight" many innocent people suffered

16

22

16

16

14

It was Stalin's huge mistake

19

14

18

21

20

It was a crime committed in cold blood, carried out by Stalin personally, to which there can be no justification

19

18

17

20

19

Not Stalin alone was guilty of the repressions but the entire system of government created by him

33

28

32

32

38

Hard to say

11

16

15

10

8

There was a "cleaning" in the military in 1937. Many of the popular military leaders had to undergo repressions. How do you think it affected the country's defence potential? (a close-end question, one response possible)

 

Total respondents

Age, years

18-24

25-34

35-44

45-59

60 and more

"cleaning" strengthened the Soviet Army before the start of the war and positively influenced the country's defence potential

3

3

2

2

5

2

It did not have any impact on the country's defence potential

9

9

10

9

9

9

It was one of the reasons of the failures of our army at the beginning of the war

70

62

65

74

72

72

Hard to say

18

26

23

15

14

17


Read the article in Russian