Thematic rubrics

Home  >  News  >  Press-releases  >  Press-release Send Link by  Email Print Version

VCIOM Press-release

02.11.2009

Prese-release № 1227

 

 

BATTLE FOR HISTORY:

"Us" vs. "Them" and Dogmas  vs. Free Flow of Ideas

MOSCOW, October 21, 2009. Russian Public Opinion Research Centre (VCIOM) presents the data whether Russians are interested in Russian history, what opinion towards review and revision of historical events they have, and whether they think it is acceptable to have several history textbooks at the same time (instead of one). 

Over the recent years Russians` interest in history has increased: the number of those who are fond of history in varying degree has grown from 39 to 62%.  Most of them are respondents with high level of education (72%) and residents of middle-sized cities (68%). At the same time, the proportion of those who demonstrate no interest in Russian history has decreased from 54 to 38%. Most of them are Russians with low level of education (54%), and residents of small cities and rural area (40-41%).

According to a majority of Russians, the evaluation of historical events should be done only once, and the revision of history is not acceptable (60%).  Most of those who have such an opinion are Muscovites and St.Petersburgians (68%) and elderly citizens (66%). Nevertheless, almost every third consider that the process of writhing history is endless and each generation reinterprets history in terms of its knowledge (31%). Such position is typical for inhabitants of middle-sized cities (39%) and respondents younger than 34 (38%).

Sixty-one percent of Russians are confident that "national histories" are not acceptable, and historical truth is one and for all. Most of respondents who hold this opinion are metropolitan residents (79%), and CPRF and Fair Russia supporters (66% for each).  On the contrary, 31% of respondents think that historical events can be interpreted in a different way by different nations - they are basically residents of middle-sized cities (39%) and LDPR adherents (33%).

History is a science and instrument of cognition (66%). Only 26% of respondents think that history does not exist outside of politics and political struggle. The former position is held by the Fair Russia party supporters (73%) and those who are interested in history a lot (77%). They are opposed by LDPR adherents (33%) and those who have never been interested in history (34%).

Russians have an unambiguous opinion towards school history textbooks: 79% think that the textbook should be single for all schools. Most of those who think so are elderly citizens (86%) and southerners (93%). Those who support the idea of a number of school textbooks to be chosen from are in the minority (15%); they are basically 18-24-yar-old Russians (21%), residents of the Urals and Siberia (23% for each).

Those in favor of a single textbook for all schools are mainly respondents who are interested in Russian history (84%). Those Russians who have never been interested in history are basically in favor of a number of school textbooks (18%).

 The initiative Russian opinion polls were conducted on October 3-4, 2009. 1600 respondents were interviewed at 140 sampling points in 42 regions of Russia. The margin of error does not exceed 3.4 %.

Are you interested in history in general?

(close-ended question, one answer)

 

2007

2009

Very interested; I read a lot of books, watch historical movies, visit museums

7

16

Interested from time to time when I have a desire and an opportunity

32

46

rather not interested; history was interesting at school (university), but I do not have neither time nor desire for it

36

27

I have never been interested in history, and I am not interested now

18

11

Hard to tell

6

1

Lots of historical events have been revised and reinterpreted recently. What is your attitude to it?

 (close-ended question, one answer)

 

Total respondents

Age, years

18-24

25-34

35-44

45-59

60 and above

The process of writing history is endless. Historical events cannot be interpreted unambiguously, because history is being written by people, and each generation reinterpret historical process in terms of its knowledge and attitudes

31

38

38

33

29

23

The evaluation of historical events should be single, unchangeable and strictly scientific; it should not be dependable on time. One should fix historical events as they happened and never change them again

60

54

56

59

62

66

Hard to tell

9

9

6

8

10

12

Same historical events look differently depending on nations. For example, both Russians and French regard the Borodino battle victory theirs. What do you think about it?

(close-ended question, one answer)

 

Total respondents

Type of settlement

Moscow and ST.Petersburg

More than  500 thousand

100-500 thousand

Less than 100 thousand

Rural area

It is a normal situation when different nations reinterpret historical events in a different way

31

23

27

39

31

31

 "National histories" are not acceptable. Historical truth should be single for everyone.

61

73

64

59

58

59

Hard to tell

8

4

9

2

11

10

Which of the following statements are you most agree? (close-ended question, one answer)

 

Total respondents

Parties which Russians would vote for,

 if elections to the State Duma took place next Sunday

United Russia

CPRF

LDPR

Fair Russia

Other  (Pravoe Delo, Patriots of Russia, Yabloko)

I would not take part in elections

History is a science, instrument of cognition, but not political manipulations. History should be studied by scientists; politicians should not interfere with this process.

66

67

67

61

73

71

64

History cannot exist outside of politics; history is one of effective instruments of political struggle; politics cannot influence history in principle.

26

26

21

33

22

29

26

Hard to tell

8

7

12

6

5

0

11

Do you think there should be the only one textbook approved by the Ministry of Education for use in schools or there should be a number of such textbooks?

(close-ended question, one answer)

 

Total respondents

Age, years

18-24

25-34

35-44

45-59

60 and above

There should be a single history textbook, that would exclude any confusion

79

73

76

77

81

86

There should be a number of textbooks to be chosen from

15

21

18

15

14

9

Hard to tell

6

6

5

8

5

6

Note: Using materials from the site www.wciom.ru or www.wciom.com, as well as distributed by VCIOM, the reference to the source (or hyperlink for the electronic media) is obligatory!

 





Comments

Please login or register
Login Password
Forgot your password?



Related materials:

27.05.2010

Prese-release № 1273

WORLD WAR II

подробнее
11.05.2010

Prese-release № 1270

THINKING OF V.I. LENIN TODAY

подробнее
13.04.2010

More Russians believe in Perestroika, opinion poll reveals

The number of Russians who are unhappy with the results of Perestroika launched by former Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev in April 1985 has almost halved over the last 10 years, from 75pc to 42pc, according to a poll carried out in January by VTsIOM (the All-Russian Public Opinion Research Centre) among residents of 140 locations in Russia.

подробнее
07.04.2010

Prese-release № 1257

AGAIN ABOUT PERESTROIKA: HISTORICAL RETROSPECTIVE  REVIEW

подробнее


Search the website

Tendencies

Did you experience any pressure (or restrictions) from federal, regional, or local authorities in 2009 when deciding on the following issues...? (close-ended question, any number of answers, answer "yes") 

1600 respondents were interviewed at 140 sampling points in 42 regions of Russia.
The margin of error does not exceed 3.4%.